Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
PASSIONATE MARTINI
CARAJILLO
SMOKED VANILLA APPLE OLD FASHIONED
THE COOPERSMITH
About
Bull Smith's Tavern
Welcome to Bull Smith's Tavern, a vibrant addition to the dining scene at 155 W Main St, Smithtown, NY. This modern tavern has undergone an impressive renovation, transforming the old Croxley's into a welcoming space filled with light and a lively atmosphere. With a touch of rustic charm and a contemporary open concept, it offers a perfect backdrop for gatherings, celebrations, or simply unwinding after a long day.
At Bull Smith's, the emphasis is on quality. The menu features top-tier bar food, making it an ideal spot for casual bites or hearty meals. Guests rave about their experience, especially on events like Monday wing night and the popular Taco Tuesdays, where flavor meets value. The food comes out promptly and fresh, a testament to the kitchen’s capability and commitment to excellence.
The drink selection is equally enticing. With a creative cocktail menu, patrons can indulge in unique offerings such as the Passionate Martini made with Tito's vodka and passion fruit juice, or the Smoked Vanilla Apple Old Fashioned that brings a twist to a classic. For those looking to share a festive experience, the Mimosa Tower is a standout choice at 100oz, perfect for larger gatherings.
What truly sets Bull Smith's apart, however, is the exceptional service. Customers repeatedly mention the friendly and energetic staff who create a warm and welcoming ambiance. Servers like Nicollete and Ava have garnered special recognition for their attentiveness and enthusiasm, enhancing the overall dining experience.
Whether you’re celebrating a milestone like a graduation or just enjoying a night out with friends while watching a game, Bull Smith's Tavern promises an unforgettable experience. As one guest aptly described, it’s "Long Island's hidden treasure"—a place where delicious food, creative drinks, and a lively atmosphere come together to create lasting memories.
If you haven’t visited yet, make it your next stop. You won’t just enjoy a meal; you’ll be part of a community enthusiastic about great food, good company, and memorable nights.
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Couldn’t be happier to have this open recently by me. They did an amazing renovation job on the old Croxleys. The venue is open concept and full of light. Love the garage door windows and outside bar seating. Food I’ve tried so far had been solid bar food. Great deal on taco Tuesdays. Best part of my visits have been the amazing staff. Young, energetic and friendly it’s a welcoming and refreshing scene. It’s already a regular stop. Only suggestion would be adding some happy hour food specials ”
“ Came here to celebrate my brother getting into grad school. Nicollete was our waitress. Had an amazing time. Live music was great, drinks were flowing. Had a great time. 100% would come back just for Nicollete! ”
“ We very much enjoyed our trip to Bull Smiths for Monday wing night. 1 wings, good fresh beer, great atmosphere and friendly personable service from Megan and Nicolette. The restaurant is clean, modern and presentable and the food is top tier, fresh and came out very quickly. I am so excited for the summer spending nights drinking at their bar and Bull Smith’s will be my go to place from now on. ”
“ After our plans to celebrate my daughter’s 25th birthday in Florida were cancelled due to hurricane Milton, we decided on happy hour at Bull Smith’s! Couldn’t have had a better time. Apps and drinks were great. Ava our server was amazing and did an incredible job. I reserved a fire pit area for my daughter and friends to hang out at which was also a great idea. I was allowed to bring in a cake which the staff graciously cut too. Great time was had by all!! We will definitely be going back in the future. Thanks so much for helping make my daughter’s birthday special! ”
“ This is Long Island's hidden treasure! What a great time we had, I got to meet Max and his team, they are all great! Their chicken wings are fabulous and their beer selections to die for! Highly recommended if you want to have a good time with friends and see a good baseball game! In one word, Fantastic! Merci!! ”
“ We started going during the NY Mets watch parties and was able to get photos and signatures from the great players that we met. Our favorite so for was HoJo - Howard Johnson , he was very friendly and down to earth. This is a great place to go and enjoy the crowd and atmosphere. ”
“ Always a fun place to meet friends for a drink and a bite to eat. Great atmosphere and we enjoy the outdoor seating in the summer. Fantastic entertainment and energy in all seasons. ”
“ I like this place a lot. I thought the food was good as well as the atmosphere. The staff were very nice, our server Megan was sweet and took care of us. I will definitely be returning in the summer for the outside area. ”